Benefit-cost analysis of moist exposed burn ointment
毕莎拉 阿提叶 鲁瓦达 达姆 穆罕默德 卡都利 阿布得 法塔 阿布达拉 马呣 阿乐噢忒菲 欧斯曼 法替 阿梅 萨米耳
摘 要:烧伤是对病人破坏性最大的一种伤害.尽管在经济落后的地区,医疗机构也会应用大量的医疗资源配以高质量的监护和临床关注来治疗烧伤,但却很少关注管理成本这个问题.很少有关于烧伤治疗成本的调查,健康服务人员在这方面的研究也是最少的.尽管如此,烧伤创面的局部治疗费用占病人每日治疗费用的一大部分.经济时代在变迁,市场也渗透到了有组织的健康医疗中,健康医疗产业的竞争也更加激烈.在不影响治疗质量的前提下,怎样减少花费成为首要的问题.我们在上报道了一个前瞻性的随机对比研究,分析了应用湿润烧伤膏的成本效益值,这是一种治疗烧伤的暴露疗法,与以往封闭创面方法不同的是,它不需要再用敷料覆盖.
关键词:效益-成本分析;湿润烧伤膏;烧伤治疗
分类号:F224.5 文献标识码:A
文章编号:1001-0726(2004)01-0072-05
作者单位:毕莎拉 阿提叶(美国大学贝鲁特医疗中心整形和重建外科,贝鲁特,黎巴嫩)
鲁瓦达 达姆(药物研究中心,迪拜,阿联酋)
穆罕默德 卡都利(开罗大学,开罗,埃及)
阿布得 法塔 阿布达拉(亚力山大大学医院,亚力山大,埃及)
马呣 阿乐噢忒菲(亚西乌特,大学医院,亚西乌特,埃及)
欧斯曼 法替(爱资哈尔,大学医院,开罗,埃及)
阿梅 萨米耳(扎卡吉克,大学医院,扎卡吉克,埃及)
参考文献:
[1]J.J.Mathews,K.Supple,A.Calistro and R.L. Gamelli, A burn center cost-reduction program[J].J.Burn Care Rehabil.18(1997),pp.358-363.
[2]F.G.Torrati,L.A.Rossi,E.Ferreira,M.C.B.Dalri et al., Analysis of cost of dressing in the care of burn patients[J].Burns 26(2000),pp.289-293.
[3]J.R.Weeler.R Van Harrinson, R.A.Wolfe and B.C.Payne,The effect of burn severity and institutional differences on the costs of care[J].Med.Care31(1983),pp.1192-1203.
[4]B.S.Linn,S.E.Stephenson,P.R.Bergstresser and J.Smith, Do dollars spent relate to outcomes in burn care?[J].Med.Care17(1979),p.835.
[5]T.T.Nguyen,D.A.Gilpin,N.A.Meyer and D.N.Herndon, Current treatment of severely burned patiens[J].Ann.Surg.223(1996),pp.14-25.
[6]J.A.Lofts,Cost analysis of a major burn[J]. N.Z.Med.J.16(1991),pp.488-490.
[7]A.M. Munster,M.Smith-Meek and P.Sharkey,The effect of early surgieal intervention on mortality and cost-effectiveness in burn care(1978-91)[J]. Burns 20 (1994),pp.61-64.
[8]P.I.Ramzi,J.P.Barret and D.N.Herndon,Thermal injury[J].crit.care clin. 15(1999),pp.333-352.
[9]R.L.Sheridan, L.Petras,M.Lydon and P.M.Salvo, Once daily wound cleansing and dressing change;efficacy and cost[J].J.Burn Care Rehabl.18(1997),pp.139-140.
[10]B.S.Atiyeh,G.Ghanimeh,I.L.Kaddoura,C.Al Amm and J.Ioannovich, Split thickness skin graft donor site dressing; preliminary results of controlled clinical comparative study of MEBO and Sofratulle[J]. Ann.Plast.Surg.46(2001),pp.87-88[letter to the editor].
[11]B.S.A TIYEH,J.Ioannovich and C.A.Al Amm,Pansements de sites donneurs de greffe de peau mince; resultats preliminaires d' une etude clinique limitee comparative de MEBO et de sofratulle[J]. Brulures Rev. Francaise de Brulol.1(2000),pp.155-161.
[12]J.Ioannovich,E.Tsati,D.Tsoutsos,K.Frangia et al., Moist exposed burn therapy;evaluation of the epithelial repair process (an experimental mode1)[J].Ann.Burns Fire Disast.8(2000),pp.3-9.
[13]T.G.Ganiats and L.J.Schneiderman,Principles of cost-effectiveness[J].J.fam.Pract.1(1988),pp.77-84.
[14]N.P.Couch,N.L.Tilney,A.A.Rayner and F.D.Moore.The high cost of low frequency events;the anatomy and economics of surgical mishaps[J].New Engl.J.Med. 304(1981),pp.634-637.
[15]Y.Y.Qu,Y.P.Wang,S.C.Qiu,B.Q.Li et al.,Experimental study on the anti-infection effect of moist exposed burn ointment[J].Chin.J.Burns Wounds Surf.Ulcers9(1997),pp.4-9.
[16]Y.Y.Qu,Y.P.Wang.S.C.Qiu,T.Hu et al., Experimental study on the anti-infective mechanism of moist exposed burn ointment[J].Chin.J.Burns Wounds surf.ulcers8(1996),pp.19-23.
[17]D.Xing, Experimental study on the actions of the moist burn ointment on promoting healing and anti-infection[J].chin.J.Burns Wounds surf.ulcers1(1996),pp.76-77.
[18]B.S.Atiyeh,J.Iannovich,G.Magliacani,M.Masellis and M.Ccostagliola, Efficacy of moist exposed burn ointment in the management of cutaneous wounds and ulcers;a multicenter pilot study[J].Ann.Plast.Surg.48(2002),pp.226-227.